Debate Sparks Over Ballot Paper Use in Local Body Elections

Swift Summary

• Karnataka government plans to reintroduce ballot papers in upcoming local body elections.
• Current and retired election officials criticized the move, citing concerns over easier manipulation and malpractice in local body polls.
• Reverting to ballot papers would increase financial and environmental costs, requiring significant resources for printing, storage, guarding, and counting ballots.
• Officials advocate for enhanced trust-building mechanisms with evms like VVPAT audits, public demonstrations of machines, political party involvement in processes like randomization and data security during vote counting.
• Former Chief Election Commissioner Navin Chawla defended EVMs as environmentally sustainable and more foolproof against tampering compared to ballot papers.
• A retired State Election Commissioner noted challenges in using EVMs for multi-member Gram Panchayat wards but added that EVMs remain suitable for Zilla Parishad/municipal corporation elections conducted on party lines.

Indian Opinion Analysis
The decision to revert to ballot papers raises critical points about electoral integrity versus operational practicality. While skepticism regarding Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) has been voiced by several stakeholders over time, experts largely emphasize trust-building measures rather than abandoning the system altogether-highlighting options like VVPAT audits and obvious processes involving political parties.

Environmental sustainability also plays a pivotal role; large-scale paper usage could have lasting ecological consequences. The bigger challenge lies in balancing operational feasibility with voter confidence: Gram Panchayat elections may require alternatives due to their unique complexities where official concerns are valid but must avoid regressive steps at a broader level where newer technologies prove efficient.

For India’s democratic ethos to evolve effectively, mechanisms bolstering public trust alongside resource optimization deserve priority focus over reverting decades-old practices fraught with logistical impediments.

Read more: Source