Petitioner Challenges EC in Supreme Court Over Vulnerability of SIR Verification Documents

Quick Summary

• The NGO Association for Democratic Rights contested the Election Commission of India (EC)’s rejection of Aadhaar, voter ID, adn ration card as valid standalone proof for inclusion in Bihar’s electoral roll during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).
• earlier, on July 10, the Supreme Court had asked the EC to consider these three documents along with 11 othre eligibility documents.
• The EC argued that Aadhaar, Electoral Photo Identity Card (EPIC), and ration cards are more prone to forgery compared to other approved documentation.
• The NGO countered this justification by stating all approved eligibility documents are similarly susceptible to fraud and termed the EC’s rationale as arbitrary and inconsistent.
• Data referenced by the NGO revealed discrepancies in document numbers exceeding Bihar’s population total; this raised concerns about selective acceptance of proof.
• the NGO also questioned why widely-used Aadhaar was excluded despite being foundational in acquiring several approved eligibility proofs like caste or residence certificates.
• Concerns were raised over potential voter disenfranchisement due to insufficient time for re-enrollment before Bihar Assembly elections in November.

Indian Opinion Analysis
The dispute over acceptable voter registration proofs highlights deeper systemic challenges within India’s electoral process concerning identity verification. While maintaining accuracy is critical for preventing fraud, outright refusal of commonly-held identification like Aadhaar or Voter ID risks alienating legitimate voters from participation-especially given their integral role in obtaining essential documentation listed under eligibility criteria. The NGO’s critique suggests inconsistencies that warrant scrutiny regarding the execution fairness within SIR.

Electoral integrity depends on balancing inclusivity while eliminating risks of manipulation or duplication; any large-scale verification drive such as SIR must be feasible and equitable without compromising timelines vital for election readiness-a concern especially pressing with looming Bihar polls. How these issues are resolved could set an important precedent for future nationwide exercises around voter rolls.

Read more: Original Article