Congress, VCK Challenge Stalin’s Stance Against Special Law on ‘Honour’ Killings

Speedy Summary

• Allies of the DMK, including Congress, VCK, CPI-M, adn various activists, are urging the Tamil Nadu government to pass a special legislation to address caste-hatred-driven murders frequently enough termed as ‘honor crimes.’
• The demand follows the murder of kavin Selvaganesh in Tirunelveli, an engineer from a Scheduled Caste community.
• Chief Minister M.K. Stalin had earlier stated in the Assembly that existing laws and stringent enforcement were adequate to deal with such crimes.
• Tamil Nadu Congress Committee president K. Selvaperunthagai opposed the Chief Minister’s view and argued for a separate law targeting honour-related crimes. He pointed out that other states have enacted similar laws.
• Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK) leader Thol Thirumavalavan criticized continued caste-related violence in southern districts such as Tirunelveli and Thoothukudi while demanding specialized police intelligence units to curb caste-based crime.
• The Supreme Court’s 2018 Shakti Vahini case recommended enacting specific legislation for honour killings nationwide but has not been implemented by state or national governments.
• A civil rights organization representative from Evidence highlighted limitations of current legal frameworks like SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities Act when addressing certain forms of honor-related violence.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The renewed call for exclusive legislation on caste-hatred-induced murders reflects persistent concerns about inadequate legal mechanisms to address deeply entrenched societal issues like caste-based violence in Tamil Nadu. While some political leaders argue that existing laws are sufficient when enforced rigorously, others assert that passing targeted laws could enhance awareness and protection mechanisms for marginalized groups.

The broader debate signals both structural challenges within India’s justice systems and social barriers obstructing equality-issues requiring focused governance interventions alongside legislative reforms. The Supreme Court’s previous endorsement of separate laws highlights potential gaps between judicial advocacy and executive implementation across states. Should Tamil Nadu move forward with specialized legislation on ‘honour crimes,’ it may set precedents encouraging systemic change beyond its borders.

Read more: Original Article