Circular Motion’ Review: A Dystopia That Cuts Deep

Quick Summary

• The New Scientist Book Club reviewed Circular Motion by Alex Foster, a dystopian sci-fi novel.
• The book explores the consequences of Earth’s accelerating rotation due to massive aircraft facilitating global air travel (“Westward Circuit”),leading to 2-hour days and severe environmental impacts.
• Readers shared mixed reactions: some appreciated its character-driven approach and parallels to climate change, while others found the dystopia too overwhelming or struggled with suspension of disbelief regarding the underlying physics.
• Themes about hubris and humanity’s tendency to ignore impending disasters resonated strongly, drawing parallels with real-world issues like climate collapse and technological “fixes.”
• Criticism included lack of exploration of broader biosphere effects, representation of marginalized groups disproportionately affected by crises, and insufficient focus on speculative science elements.
• The next book selected for discussion is Ursula K. Le Guin’s classic The Dispossessed, accompanied by an essay from her son.

!The New Scientist Book Club

Indian Opinion Analysis

Alex Foster’s Circular Motion, although fictional, presents crucial parallels to contemporary global challenges like climate change. By tackling themes such as technological hubris-attempting fixes rather than addressing root causes-the story mirrors ongoing debates around enduring practices versus innovation-driven solutions in India. Critics’ concerns about disproportionate impacts on less privileged groups resonate with patterns observed in India’s own struggle against climate inequality.

As readers point out gaps in exploring ecological fallout beyond human-centric narratives, this critique might serve as inspiration for Indian writers delving into futuristic fiction informed by biodiverse realities closer to home. A stronger emphasis on socio-economic disparities could heighten engagement in conversations around equitable responses to crises-a discussion relevant not just globally but deeply rooted within India’s developmental paradigm.

Read More: