Doctors Raise Concerns Over NOTTO’s Organ Donation Advisory

Rapid Summary

• The National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organisation (NOTTO) issued a contentious 10-point advisory to States and Union Territories to enhance organ donation and transplantation in India.
• Recommendations include:

– Additional allocation points for women on transplant waiting lists to address gender disparity.
– Priority for near relatives of previous deceased donors needing transplants.
– Mandatory sharing of donor and recipient data with the national registry.

• Suggestions also involve honoring deceased donors with dignified funerals and recognizing their families at public functions.
• Critics argue ther are no existing protocols for prioritizing certain groups,such as women or relatives,questioning feasibility and fairness.
• concerns were raised over the Center encroaching on state powers regarding public health policy through mandates like data-sharing requirements.
• Proposed promotion of ayurveda, yoga, and healthy lifestyles was criticized by experts as needless in evidence-based medical practices.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The advisory reflects an effort by NOTTO to streamline organ donation efforts but has sparked significant debate among stakeholders. While addressing gender disparity is commendable,implementing specific prioritization criteria raises practical concerns about fairness,protocols,and potential unintended consequences. similarly, granting priority to relatives of past donors may conflict with global altruistic principles that have guided organ donations as inception.

The push for mandatory data-sharing can improve transparency but might strain relationships between State governments and the Centre if it is perceived as infringing upon federal autonomy in healthcare governance. The suggested inclusion of ayurveda or yoga appears unrelated to core transplant objectives, diluting focus from critical issues requiring immediate attention.

A deeper consultative process involving all stakeholders-patients, medical experts, hospitals, states-is necessary before implementing these contentious points to ensure efficiency without compromising equity or jurisdictional harmony.

Read more: Source Link