Judicial Reshuffles Prolong Trial in North-East Delhi Riots Case

Rapid Summary

• The trial in the ‘larger conspiracy’ case related to the 2020 north-east Delhi riots,which resulted in 53 deaths and over 700 injuries,will begin afresh due to judicial reshuffle.
• A recent transfer of judges has reassigned the case to Additional Sessions Judge (ASJ) Lalit Kumar, succeeding ASJ Sameer Bajpai.
• On June 2, arguments on charges were partially completed with submissions from a special Public Prosecutor and five accused individuals.
• ASJ Kumar has directed all parties involved to submit time estimates for further arguments by June 6 to determine a timeline for hearings going forward.
• The original case was filed under provisions of UAPA by Delhi Police’s Special Cell in 2020; key accused include Tahir Hussain,student activists Umar Khalid,Safoora Zargar,Sharjeel Imam,and several others. This is after months of delays during investigations and prior judge transfers dating back several years.

Read More

Indian Opinion Analysis

The repeated reshuffling of judges in the ongoing trial underscores significant procedural challenges within India’s judiciary when handling complex cases like this one involving alleged conspiracy under stringent laws such as UAPA. While legal processes can understandably take years due to evidence gathering and rigorous scrutiny over charges against multiple high-profile defendants, frequent disruptions erode public trust and highlight inefficiencies-especially for victims awaiting justice after tragic riots that disrupted lives deeply.

The direction by ASJ Lalit Kumar seeking precise timelines from both prosecution teams and defense counsels appears pragmatic but hinges on strict adherence moving forward to avoid undue delays further stretching an already prolonged judicial narrative spanning half a decade as the filing began first originating By requesting structured argument order optimism ensuring opposing delays aligning best adjudicating transparent scrutiny accountability balancing horrific/politicized clash devastation