Punjab Finance Minister Cheema Slams Centre’s GST Rate Rationalisation as ‘Irresponsible

Quick Summary

• Punjab Finance Minister Harpal Singh Cheema criticized the Central government for “irresponsible” GST rate rationalization and it’s impact on states’ finances.
• Punjab claims to have suffered a financial loss of ₹1,11,045 crore as GST implementation in 2017.
• The state received approximately ₹60,000 crore as compensation from the Center but demands ₹50,000 crore more to cover remaining losses.
• Mr. Cheema highlighted that the promised 5-year compensation package for states has been discontinued by the Central government.
• He accused the BJP-led Union government of withholding additional funds amounting to ₹8,000 crore (rural advancement) and over ₹1,000 crore (Prime Minister’s Road Scheme).
• Mr. Cheema voiced concerns that repeated changes in GST rates create uncertainty among taxpayers and harm India’s financial framework.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The dispute between Punjab’s Finance Minister Harpal Singh Cheema and the Union government underscores ongoing challenges in implementing a unified Goods and Services Tax system across India. While rate rationalization aims to simplify taxation for economic efficiency, it raises broader questions about state-level fiscal autonomy under India’s federal structure. Punjab’s demand for pending compensation reflects concerns shared by many states regarding post-GST revenue shortfalls.If unresolved promptly, this disagreement may exacerbate tensions between state governments reliant on these allocations and an increasingly centralized tax collection model managed by New Delhi. The allegations regarding withheld developmental funds further highlight a potential strain on cooperative federalism-an essential principle of governance within India’s diverse economic landscape.

Read more: Source Link