Supreme Court Declines Ilaiyaraaja’s Request to Move Copyright Case to Madras HC

Quick Summary

• The Supreme Court of India dismissed a plea by legendary composer Ilaiyaraaja on July 28,2025.
• Ilaiyaraaja sought to transfer a copyright dispute involving over 500 musical compositions from the Bombay High court to the Madras High Court.
• Sony Music Entertainment initiated the case in 2022 before the bombay High court,seeking an injunction to restrain Ilaiyaraaja Music N Management Pvt Ltd (IMMPL) from using 536 works.
• Sony claims rights via acquisition from Oriental Records and Echo Recording, with which Ilaiyaraaja has an ongoing legal battle.
• IMMPL contended that 310 of these works are already under scrutiny in an older case filed by Ilaiyaraaja in Madras High court since 2014.
• A key judgment in that earlier matter upheld certain moral and special rights of Ilaiyaraaja as a composer.
• The Supreme Court bench included Chief Justice B.R. Gavai and Justices K Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria.

Indian Opinion Analysis

This Supreme Court ruling centers on jurisdiction rather than resolving ownership or usage disputes concerning musical works by one of India’s iconic composers, highlighting how complex copyright law has become in today’s creative industries. While Sony Music emphasizes its proprietary rights over specific works acquired through formal channels, IMMPL stresses overlapping judicial matters tied to earlier suits where aspects of moral and economic rights earned recognition.

The decision preserves jurisdictional conditions for ongoing cases but underscores broader systemic challenges artists face when protecting intellectual property, especially when disputes span multiple jurisdictions or relate to decades-old agreements. For India’s cultural ecosystem-where safeguarding creative ownership is vital-this highlights important gaps between historical practices versus new legal dynamics shaping content ownership today.

Read more at: Source